Recruiting Manager

We are looking for an experienced and strategic Recruiting Manager to lead and build out talent acquisition within our high-growth insurance organization. In this role, you will develop and execute recruitment strategies that attract top-tier talent across claims, tech, customer service, and corporate support functions. You will also shape the recruiting function itself: the team, the process, and the systems behind it. The ideal candidate has set up a recruiting department before and brings a strong track record of building, coaching, and growing high-performing recruiting teams.

Who you are:

• Influential: You have the ability to influence and motivate the people around you, whether stakeholders, your team, or candidates. Your influence builds alignment, trust, and action.
• Respected: You earn the respect of your team. Recruiters trust your judgment and your standards because you lead by example and hold yourself to the same bar you set for them.
• Growth-Oriented Leadership: You know how to coach and grow recruiters. You bring proven strategies for developing talent, upskilling your team, and creating meaningful opportunities for professional growth, fostering a culture of continuous learning.
• Attentive & Hardworking: You pay attention to the details and you put in the work. You stay close to your pipeline, your team, and your hiring partners, and you follow through to get roles filled well.
• Innovative & Curious: You're always exploring ways to improve processes, increase efficiency, enhance the candidate experience, and attract top talent. We value and welcome your creative ideas.
• Accountable: You clearly define expectations, take full ownership of your actions and your team's outcomes, and work with integrity. You hold yourself and others responsible for delivering results.
• Collaborative: You thrive in a team-first environment. You value partnership, support your peers, and believe that when one of us succeeds, we all succeed.
• Organized: You simplify complex problems and communicate clearly with stakeholders to ensure objectives are understood and achieved.
• Flexible: You're agile and adaptable, ready to pivot quickly in response to change and challenge without losing momentum.
• Communicative: You're a proactive communicator who shares the right information before being asked, ensuring clarity, alignment, and trust.
• Data-Driven: You set clear goals and identify the right metrics to track success. You use data to inform decisions, measure performance, and drive continuous improvement.

What we need:

• Build and Lead the Recruiting Team: Lead, develop, and grow a team of recruiters responsible for sourcing and hiring talent across all functions of the business. Set the structure, standards, and ways of working that let the team scale with the company.
• Partner with Business Leaders: Collaborate closely with leaders across departments to understand hiring needs, develop tailored strategies, and address hard-to-fill roles.
• Build and Maintain Talent Pipelines: Proactively source and nurture a pipeline of qualified candidates to meet current and future hiring demands.
• Drive Full-Cycle Recruitment: Manage the end-to-end recruitment process, including sourcing, interviewing, candidate selection, and offer management.
• Optimize Recruiting Processes: Evaluate, implement, and refine recruiting workflows to increase efficiency and deliver a strong candidate experience.
• Leverage Data and Analytics: Use recruiting metrics to track performance, uncover trends, and continuously improve hiring strategies.
• Ensure Compliance: Maintain full compliance with employment laws, insurance industry hiring standards, and internal company policies throughout all recruitment efforts.
• Employer Brand Strategy: Design and execute strategies to elevate and promote the company's employer brand in the market.

Qualifications:

• Experience building or standing up a recruiting function. You have set up a recruiting department before, or built one out substantially, and you know what it takes to get from scratch to a working, scalable operation.
• 8+ years of recruiting experience, including 4+ years directly managing recruiters.
• A track record of coaching, developing, and growing recruiters into stronger performers.
• Proficiency with applicant tracking systems (e.g., Rippling and Greenhouse).
• Strong communication, stakeholder management, and organizational skills.
• Comfortable operating in a fast-paced, metrics-driven environment.
• Bachelor's degree in Human Resources, Business, or a related field (lack of one should not stop you from applying if you bring the experience).

Preferred Skills:

• Experience recruiting within the insurance industry (specifically P&C would be helpful)
• Understanding of insurance-related job functions and regulatory hiring requirements, including licensed adjusters and compliance-sensitive roles.
• Insurance-related education or certification (e.g., CPCU, AINS).
• Familiarity with remote workforce hiring strategies.
• Knowledge of talent sourcing tools (e.g., LinkedIn Recruiter, Indeed, and niche job boards).

Benefits:

• Generous health-insurance package with nationwide coverage, vision, & dental
• 401(k) retirement plan with employer matching
• Competitive PTO policy – we want our employees fresh, healthy, happy, and energized!
• Generous family leave policy after 8 months of continuous work
• Work from anywhere to facilitate your work life balance
• Apple laptop, large second monitor, and other quality-of-life equipment you may want. Technology is something that should make your life easier, not harder!

At Reserv, we value diversity in backgrounds, perspectives, and life experiences and believe that diversity in viewpoints and critical thinking drives innovation, first-principles thinking, and success. We welcome applicants from all backgrounds and encourage those from all walks of life to apply. If you believe you are a good fit for this role, we would love to hear from you!