Insurance Sales Producer (High-Earning | Competitive | Structured | Growth-Focused)

Elliot Dudley-Farmers Insurance Agency

TEMPE, AZ

JOB DETAILS
SALARY
$74,500–$240,000 Per Year
LOCATION
TEMPE, AZ
POSTED
Today

Job Description

This role is for someone who wants clear goals, real accountability, and real upside without the burden of running an agency or managing others.

As a Sales Producer at the Elliot Dudley Agency, your primary responsibility is to convert conversations into premium, build long-term client relationships, and grow a profitable book of business. Youll be supported by proven systems, exact scripts, daily coaching, and marketing support so you can focus on what you do best: selling and serving clients.


This is a fast-paced, fun, competitive role designed for confident sales professionals who want structure, coaching, and a very high earning ceiling without sacrificing lifestyle or taking a cut in pay.


Why Work at the Elliot Dudley Agency?


Elliot is a proven sales professional and coach with over 15 years of top-level performance as a high-producing sales leader. Hes a fun, driven visionary with an optimistic, upbeat personality who loves building people, systems, and winning teams.


Kacie brings the balance. She leads with a kind, people-first approach and is passionate about creating an environment that feels supportive, encouraging, and like family. With years of success across HR, insurance, and sales, she ensures the operation runs smoothly while people feel valued and cared for.


Together, were a dynamic duo high standards, high energy, and high support.


Over the past year, weve intentionally broken down and rebuilt our systems from the ground up to align with proven industry standards and best practices. We are now in a growth phase and looking for individuals who want to be front-runners, leaders, and examples as we rebuild and scale our sales team.


This isnt just a job its an opportunity to partner with us, help set the standard for future hires, and grow alongside a team that invests heavily in training, culture, and clear career paths.


Compensation & Income Expectations


This is a performance-based producer role with no income ceiling.


Production Expectations


Minimum: $40,000 in written premium per month


Realistic range: $40,000$120,000 per month


Supported by marketing, training, and proven systems


~25% close ratio assumed


Commission Structure


75% commission on new business


50% renewal commission


100% bonus eligibility for hitting production and activity benchmarks


Projected Annual Income


$40k/month: ~$70,000$90,000


$70k$90k/month: ~$120,000$180,000


$100k$120k/month: $200,000$250,000+


These are realistic, repeatable results for producers who execute the system consistently.


Who This Role Is Perfect For


This role is ideal for someone who is confident in their ability to sell and wants to earn at a high level without the stress of running an agency or managing others.


You get:


Elite commission structure


Strong support and systems


Clear expectations


No ownership headaches


No cut in pay


We offer one of the most competitive sales commission structures available, designed specifically for top producers who want focus, freedom, and income.


Career Paths & Long-Term Opportunity


This role provides options:


Career Producer: High income, no management pressure


Sales Team Lead: Salaried leadership role with overrides


Future Agency Ownership: Training and guidance available for those who want it


You dont have to choose on day one. Perform, grow, and decide when the time is right.

Salary Range: $74500.00 - $240000.00 per year


Benefits

Annual Base Salary + Commission

Flexible Schedule

Hands on Training

Mon-Fri Schedule

Excellent Hours! 8-5pm Monday Friday

25k value of proven training and coaching absolutly free

lifetime fitness cost share availability

Free Leads

Free Phone Line

State of the art built out CRM

Agency Ownership Growth trajectory

Industry leading compensation plan

No License necessary to apply

Tried and proven sales systems and structure

No license necessary to Apply!


Responsibilities

Responsibilities

Measurable Performance Goals

Primary Objective: Generate a minimum of $40,000 in written premium per month

Secondary Objective: Complete 80 new sales conversations per month

(Average of 4 new conversations per day)


Success is tracked daily, reviewed consistently, and supported with tools designed to help you win.


Sales Responsibilities


Conduct professional, needs-based sales conversations


Present and close personal and commercial insurance solutions


Handle objections with confidence and integrity


Follow exact scripts and proven sales frameworks


Complete consistent follow-up with prospects and prior-day conversations


Accurately track daily activity and production


Collaborate closely with marketing and SDR support to maximize close rates


Training & Development


Daily sales role-play and coaching


Clearly defined training paths tied directly to performance


Proven scripts and systems with a track record of success


Ongoing feedback and skill development


What Your Day will look like


8:00 AM Morning meeting, sales role-play, individual and team goal recap


9:00 AM 10:00 AM In-person marketing and relationship building


10:00 AM 12:00 PM Minimum of 2 new phone conversations


12:00 PM 1:00 PM Lunch


1:15 PM Midday recap and adjustments


1:15 PM 4:45 PM Minimum of 2 additional new conversations plus follow-up from previous days


4:45 PM Daily stats tracker submission


The structure keeps expectations clear while still allowing autonomy and momentum.


Core Values of the Agency


These are non-negotiable and guide how we work together:


Always be honest


Follow through on commitments


Bring solutions, not excuses


We win when the team wins


Be constructive, not destructive


Get 1% better every day


Always do your best


Office Environment & Culture


Supportive, competitive, high-energy team


Clear standards and accountability


Wins are celebrated


Weekly office book club:


We read books written by top performers and leaders


Focused on mindset, leadership, and personal growth


Built to help us become the best versions of ourselves



Requirements

Requirements

Inherent Traits of Successful Producers

Confident leading conversations

Competitive with yourself and the standard


Organized and disciplined


Coachable and growth-oriented


Quick thinker who adapts on the fly


Self-motivated with strong accountability


Positive, energetic, and fun to work with


Comfortable managing your own schedule


What It Takes to Be Successful


Comfort selling in person and over the phone


Ability to handle objections professionally


Willingness to role-play and train consistently


Commitment to measurable improvement


Ownership mindset results matter


Core Values of the Agency


These are non-negotiable and guide how we work together:


Always be honest


Follow through on commitments


Bring solutions, not excuses


We win when the team wins


Be constructive, not destructive


Get 1% better every day


Always do your best


Final Note


This is a high-accountability, high-reward, high-fun role for the right person.


If you want:


Clear goals


Strong coaching


Real upside


A team that wins together


Wed love to talk.


About the Company

E

Elliot Dudley-Farmers Insurance Agency