Claim Examiner - Medicare Supplement

Physicians Mutual is actively hiring Medicare Supplement Claims Examiners to join our growing Claims team! In this role, you’ll play a critical part in evaluating Medicare Supplement insurance claims and providing outstanding customer support to our policyholders.

This is a fantastic opportunity to launch or grow your career in the health insurance industry with a company known for stability and integrity.

What We Offer

• Competitive compensation (Starting at $21.42+ based on experience)
• Comprehensive training and onboarding program with insurance education
• College Assistance Program & UNO Tuition Currency
• Clear growth opportunities within the Claims department and beyond
• On- site cafeteria, fitness center, and free parking
• Access to full benefits package (medical, dental, vision, 401(k), and more)

Ready to Launch Your Career?
Be part of something meaningful. Our next Claims Examiner training class begins June 3, 2026.
Apply now to secure your spot!

• Review, analyze, and process Medicare Supplement insurance claims with accuracy and attention to detail.
• Make sound decisions to approve or deny claims based on established protocols.
• Communicate claim outcomes to policyholders and providers via phone or mail.
• Maintain productivity and quality metrics in a structured environment.

Required:

• High school diploma or equivalent.
• Strong written and verbal communication skills.
• Computer proficiency and comfort using internal claims processing systems.
• Ability to work efficiently in a fast-paced, metrics-driven setting.
• Problem-solving mindset and a keen eye for detail.
• Basic math skills for benefit and interest calculations.

Preferred:

• 1–2 years of experience in health insurance claims or a related field.
• Knowledge of Medicare Supplement insurance.

Health. Life. Retirement. The Physicians Mutual family empowers people from all walks of life to enjoy the financial security they deserve. That’s what Insurance for all of us® is about.

The Physicians Mutual family includes Physicians Mutual Insurance Company, Physicians Life Insurance Company and Physicians Select Insurance Company. Physicians Mutual offers reliable dental and supplemental health insurance, and pet insurance. Physicians Life provides important life insurance, Medicare Supplement insurance and coverage for funeral pre-planning. Physicians Select Insurance Company additionally offers exclusive Medicare Supplement insurance.

Since our start in 1902, our dedication to delivering on our promise has helped make us one of the nation’s leading health and life insurance providers. In fact, we are rated in the top 1% of insurance companies. We consistently maintain some of the highest financial strength ratings in the nation from independent insurance analysts, including A.M. Best Company and Weiss Ratings, ensuring we’ll be there for our policyowners and our employees far into the future.

But the achievement we’re most proud of? We have a 95% customer satisfaction rating — a true sign of a company dedicated to embodying its vision.