Payroll & Benefits Specialist
CFS
Madison, WI
Payroll & Benefits Specialist
Salary: $55,000 – $70,000
Why should you be interested in this Payroll & Benefits Specialist role?
• Family‑owned organization with long‑term stability and strong values
• Third‑largest company in its industry, with multiple U.S. locations
• Casual, relaxed culture with supportive leadership
• Company experiencing active growth over the next 1–2 years
• High‑impact role supporting payroll, HR, and benefits administration
Responsibilities of the Payroll & Benefits Specialist:
New Hire Processing
• Handle all new hire paperwork for hourly employees
• Review, enter, and file new hire documentation
• Ensure accurate completion and compliance, including I‑9 requirements
Benefits Administration
• Manage benefit enrollments, terminations, and changes
• Process COBRA notifications and maintain compliance
• Lead administrative responsibilities during annual open enrollment
• Communicate benefit eligibility, medical and dental plan details, and qualifying events
Payroll Support
• Enter benefit deductions, child support, garnishments, and company program deductions
• Process weekly payroll hours with accuracy
• Ensure correctness and compliance in all payroll‑related actions
Compliance & Accuracy
• Maintain accurate employee data entry with timely updates
• Respond to unemployment claims within required deadlines
• Partner closely with HR leadership, including remote team members
Qualifications of the Payroll & Benefits Specialist:
• 2+ years of experience administering employee benefits
• Understanding of medical and dental plan basics and eligibility rules
• Experience handling new hire paperwork and I‑9 compliance
• Strong attention to detail and accuracy
• Ability to manage multiple tasks and maintain compliance
• Experience with payroll deductions, garnishments, and benefit entries preferred
MaxSalary: USD70000
MinSalary: USD55000
About the Company
CFS
Founded by CPA firms in 1994, Creative Financial Staffing has spent over 30 years helping job seekers and employers succeed. In fall 2025, we rebranded as CFS—a name that reflects our full range of expertise while staying true to the trusted company you know.
CFS is the industry’s leading employee-owned staffing firm, connecting top talent in accounting, finance, technology, and human resources. We provide skilled professionals on both a temporary and permanent basis across diverse industries, leveraging our extensive network to match the right people with the right opportunities.
Our dedication to excellence extends to our award-winning culture, recognized repeatedly for growth, recruiting, workplace environment, and employee support. Honors include Forbes’ “America’s Best Recruiting and Temporary Staffing Firms,” Staffing Industry Analysts’ top U.S. staffing rankings, FlexJobs’ Top 100 Companies for Remote and Hybrid Work, Top Workplaces USA, Newsweek’s Best Practices awards, and more.