Payroll & Benefits Specialist
CFS
Madison, WI
Payroll & Benefits Specialist
A successful, family‑owned organization with locations across the United States is seeking a Payroll & Benefits Specialist to support key HR, payroll, and benefits administration functions. This company is the third‑largest in its industry, operates with a relaxed and casual environment, and is heavily focused on growth over the next one to two years.
Key Highlights
- Family‑owned company with strong values and long‑term stability
- Experiencing active growth
- Casual, relaxed, and supportive environment
Responsibilities
New Hire Processing
- Handle all new hire paperwork for hourly employees
- Review, enter, and file new hire documentation
- Ensure accurate completion and compliance (including I‑9 importance and requirements)
Benefits Administration
- Manage enrollments, terminations, and benefit changes
- Process COBRA notifications
- Lead administrative responsibilities for annual open enrollment
- Provide clear explanations of benefit eligibility, health plans, dental plans, and qualifying events
Payroll Support
- Enter benefit deductions, child support, wage garnishments, and company program deductions
- Weekly entry of of payroll hours
- Ensure accuracy and correctness in all payroll actions
Compliance & Accuracy
- Enter employee data correctly and in a timely manner
- Respond to unemployment claims accurately and within required deadlines
- Partner closely with HR leadership, including remote team members
Qualifications
- 2+ years of experience administering employee benefits
- Knowledge of medical and dental plan basics and eligibility rules
- Experience handling new hire paperwork and I‑9 requirements
- Strong attention to accuracy and detail
- Ability to manage multiple tasks and maintain compliance
- Experience with payroll deductions, garnishments, and benefit‑related entries is preferred
MaxSalary: USD70000
MinSalary: USD55000
About the Company
CFS
Founded by CPA firms in 1994, Creative Financial Staffing has spent over 30 years helping job seekers and employers succeed. In fall 2025, we rebranded as CFS—a name that reflects our full range of expertise while staying true to the trusted company you know.
CFS is the industry’s leading employee-owned staffing firm, connecting top talent in accounting, finance, technology, and human resources. We provide skilled professionals on both a temporary and permanent basis across diverse industries, leveraging our extensive network to match the right people with the right opportunities.
Our dedication to excellence extends to our award-winning culture, recognized repeatedly for growth, recruiting, workplace environment, and employee support. Honors include Forbes’ “America’s Best Recruiting and Temporary Staffing Firms,” Staffing Industry Analysts’ top U.S. staffing rankings, FlexJobs’ Top 100 Companies for Remote and Hybrid Work, Top Workplaces USA, Newsweek’s Best Practices awards, and more.