Paralegal – Insurance Defense (Dayton or Cincinnati, OH)

Paralegal – Insurance Defense (Dayton or Cincinnati, OH)Young & Alexander Co., L.P.A. – Established insurance defense firm $55,000 – $70,000 base salary | Full-time or Part-time considered | Hybrid or remote work possibility | Immediate start

We are a profitable, stable, partner-owned insurance defense firm with offices in Dayton and Cincinnati, Ohio.  We are seeking two experienced paralegals to join our team -one in our Dayton, OH, office, and one in our Cincinnati, OH, office. This role offers the possibility of hybrid or remote work for the right candidate.

You will:

• Collect, review, and summarize medical records for defense cases
• Prepare pleadings, motions, and discovery documents
• Manage discovery tasks, including requests, responses, and e-discovery
• Perform other standard paralegal duties, such as research support, trial preparation, and client correspondence
• Work closely with attorneys on high-volume litigation files (premises liability, auto/trucking, subrogation, coverage)
• Work closely with clients

We need:

• 3–5 years of paralegal experience (Ohio preferred)
• Strong skills in medical records analysis and discovery management
• Proficiency in Microsoft Office suite
• Excellent organizational skills and attention to detail
• Paralegal certificate or degree preferred

Compensation & Benefits:

• $55,000 – $70,000 base salary, based on experience
• Bonus structure
• Full health, dental, disability, and life insurance
• 401(k) with 5% match
• Paid time off and holidays
• Hybrid or remote work possibility after onboarding
• Professional development support

Why Join Us?

Litigation practice is a dynamic and rewarding field that offers the opportunity to engage in strategic litigation, while honing your skills in risk management, evidence analysis, and negotiation.  It’s ideal for those that thrive on intellectual challenges, variety in cases, and the satisfaction of achieving favorable outcomes in a fast-paced environment.  At Young & Alexander Co., L.P.A., a firm with over 100 years of history, we emphasize high-quality work in a collaborative setting, providing the stability, resources, and mentorship to build a long-term-career with strong work-life balance.   Our commitment to excellence and client service creates a supportive workplace where you can grow professionally while enjoying a balanced life.

This is a long-term position with room for growth in a stable, high-performing firm. Full-time or part-time applicants may apply. 

To apply: Email resumé, cover letter, and references to lsallot@yandalaw.com

All inquiries strictly confidential.